Use caseLive
The campaign looks good. Count what it leaves.
Jonbar plays two to five versions of a campaign on your sales history and compares what each leaves after discount, commission and shipping.
Weekly margin after commission and shipping, example campaign
- Extra revenue in the campaign weeks
- +TRY 328,320
- Extra margin after commission and shipping
- -TRY 14,688
Example shape, not a measured result.
The situation
Revenue is the number you report. Margin is the number that pays.
A 2,400 ₺ coffee machine, 90 a week: 10%, 20% or 30% off for two weeks all move units. They do not leave the same money, and the difference sits in four places.
01
The discount itself
Even on units you would sell anyway.
02
Commission on a lower price
It takes a bigger share of your margin.
03
Shipping per order
It does not get cheaper with the price.
04
The extra units
The uncertain part, read from your past campaigns.
Why this is worth rehearsing
Most campaigns do not pay for themselves.
~3/4
of promotions do not break even.
Nielsen, 39M promotional events, US CPG, via FoodNavigator~1/3
of a promotion's extra units are won from competing brands.
van Heerde, Gupta & Wittink, Journal of Marketing Research−20.3%
future revenue from existing customers after deep discounts, in a field experiment.
Anderson & Simester, Marketing Science
The rehearsal
Ten weeks, three depths, one honest total.
Pick a version. Bars are weekly margin after unit cost, commission and shipping, against the no-campaign line.
Weekly margin · Week 1-10
2,400 ₺ becomes 1,920 ₺ for two weeks.
Revenue is up by more than 300,000 ₺, yet the two weeks leave less than two normal weeks.
- Extra revenue in the window
- +TRY 328,320
- Discount, commission and shipping
- -TRY 343,008
- Extra margin, ten weeks
- -TRY 14,688
- Discount given awayTRY 190,080
- Units in the window396 units
The other use cases
Same engine, different question.
Details: inputs, outputs and honest limits
What goes in
- Weekly history per product: units, price, campaign and stock-out weeks.
- At least 2 percent-off campaigns on the product in 20 weeks.
- Each version: depth, length and start week.
- Unit cost, commission and shipping.
What you get
- Extra revenue and margin per version, side by side.
- A probable range; overlapping versions are not ranked.
- A blind check on one past campaign.
- A forecast locked before the campaign runs.
What this does not do
- The weeks after a campaign are not modelled, so a deep discount can look better than it is.
- Competitor reactions, returns, ad spend and sales your products take from each other are not modelled.
- Sales are not capped by stock; the brief names versions that could run past it.
- Only price discounts: no bundles, coupons or free-shipping thresholds yet.
- Marketplace ranking and placement are not modelled; what your past campaigns cannot show is an assumption, written in the brief.